From
The New York Times digital archives:
A Ferocious Elvis Presley: Singer Enters the Ring in 'Kid Galahad'By BOSLEY CROWTHER
THE NEW YORK TIMES
MARCH 7, 1963
The last thing you might think Elvis Presley is qualified to do is act a diffident amateur boxer who turns out to be a tiger in the professional ring. And you might well persist in that opinion after seeing him in "Kid Galahad," a sportive remake of an old Wayne Morris picture, which came to the Astor yesterday.
Mr. Presley is certainly no model for a statue of Hercules, and his skill at projecting an illusion of ferocity is of very low degree. The expanses of flesh that he exposes when he gets into boxing togs are a fair indication that most of his muscles have come from punching a guitar, and his pout when he clouts a rival bears no resemblance to a killer's slit-mouthed sneer.
Furthermore, the proclivity assigned him by his genius and William Fay's script of expressing himself at odd moments in conspiciously un-pugnacious songs, brought up from what seems a ruptured larynx, does not endow him with a gladiatorial air. No, we'll have to agree that Mr. Presley does not make a very convincing pug.
But somehow this clique-ridden picture, which has its origin in an ancient novel by Francis Wallace that has been drawn upon (or snitched from) for any number of Golden Boy films, makes a moderately genial entertainment. It's not explosive, but it has the cheerful top of a lightly romantic contrivance that ranges between comedy and spoof.
For this we can thank the other actors who played their roles ardently and Phil Karlson, who has directed at a brisk and deceptive pace. Gig Young is attractively wicked as a Catskill hotel-keeping heel who tries to lead the young boxer to slaughter so he himself may drink. Lola Albright is charmingly solicitious as Mr. Young's disillusioned girl and Joan Blackman is pretty and submissive as the last who falls for Mr. Presley's songs. Charles Bronson, Ned Glass and Robert Emhardt make good training-camp characters. For a film about a singing prize-fighter (which is silly enough) it will do.
The Cast
KID GALAHAD
Screenplay by William Fay, based on the story by Francis Wallace; directed by Phil Karlson and produced by David Weisbart for the Mirisch Company and United Artists.
At the Astor, Broadway at 45th Street. Running time: 95 minutes.
Walter Gurick . . . . . Elvis Presley
Willy Grogan . . . . . Gig Young
Dolly Fletcher . . . . . Lola Albright
Rose Grogan . . . . . Joan Blackman
Lew Nyack . . . . . Charles Bronson
Lieberman . . . . . Ned Glass
Maynard the Chef . . . . . Robert Emhardt
Otto Danzig . . . . . David Lewis
Father Higgins . . . . . Liam Redmond
Joie . . . . . Michael Dante
https://www.nytimes.com/1963/03/07/arch ... n-kid.html